Reviews

R330406A.  Pauline.

The Athenæum, 6 April 1833, p. 216.

As reprinted in The Brownings’ Correspondence, 3, 345.

There is not a little true poetry in this very little book: here and there we have a touch of the mysterious, which we cannot admire; and now and then a want of true melody, which we can forgive; with perhaps more abruptness than what is necessary; all that, however, is as a grain of sand in a cup of pure water, compared to the nature, and passion, and fancy of the poem. We open the book at random; but fine things abound: there is no difficulty in finding passages to vindicate our praise:—

 

Autumn has come—like Spring returned to us,

Won from her girlishness—like one returned

A friend that was a lover—nor forgets

The first warm love, but full of sober thoughts

Of fading years; whose soft mouth quivers yet

With the old smile—but yet so changed and still!

And here am I the scoffer, who have probed

Life’s vanity, won by a word again

Into my old life—for one little word

Of this sweet friend, who lives in loving me,

Lives strangely on my thoughts, and looks, and words,

As fathoms down some nameless ocean thing

Its silent course of quietness and joy.

O dearest, if, indeed, I tell the past,

Mayst thou forget it as a sad sick dream;

Or if it linger—my lost soul too soon

Sinks to itself, and whispers, we shall be

But closer linked—two creatures whom the earth

Bears singly—with strange feelings, unrevealed

But to each other; or two lonely things

Created by some Power, whose reign is done,

Having no part in God, or his bright world,

I am to sing; whilst ebbing day dies soft,

As a lean scholar dies, worn o’er his book,

And in the heaven stars steal out one by one,

As hunted men steal to their mountain watch.

I must not think—lest this new impulse die

In which I trust. I have no confidence,

So I will sing on—fast as fancies come

Rudely—the verse being as the mood it paints.

 

Description and sentiment are everywhere beautifully mingled:—

 

Night, and one single ridge of narrow path

Between the sullen river and the woods

Waving and muttering—for the moonless night

Has shaped them into images of life,

Like the upraising of the giant-ghosts,

Looking on earth to know how their sons fare.

Thou art so close to me, the roughest swell

Of the tree-tops hides not the panting

Of thy soft breasts; no—we will pass to morning—

Morning—the rocks, and vallies, and old woods.

How the sun brightens in the mist, and here,—

Half in the air, like creatures of the place,

Trusting the element—living on high boughs

That swing in the wind—look at the golden spray,

Flung from the foam-sheet of the cataract,

Amid the broken rocks—shall we stay here

With the wild hawks? no, ere the hot noon come

Dive we down—safe: see this our new retreat

Walled in with a sloped mound of matted shrubs,

Dark, tangled, old and green—still sloping down

To a small pool whose waters lie asleep

Amid the trailing boughs turned water-plants,

And tall trees over-arch to keep us in,

Breaking the sunbeams into emerald shafts,

And in the dreamy water one small group

Of two or three strange trees are got together,

Wondering at all around—as strange beasts herd

Together far from their own land—all wildness—

No turf nor moss, for boughs and plants pave all,

And tongues of bank go shelving in the waters,

Where the pale-throated snake reclines his head,

And old grey stones lie making eddies there;

The wild mice cross them dry-shod—deeper in—

Shut thy soft eyes—now look—still deeper in:

This is the very heart of the woods—all round,

Mountain-like, heaped above us; yet even here

One pond of water gleams—far off the river

Sweeps like a sea, barred out from land; but one—

One thin clear sheet has over-leaped and wound

Into this silent depth, which gained, it lies

Still, as but let by sufferance; the trees bend

O’er it as wild men watch a sleeping girl,

And thro’ their roots long creeping plants stretch out

Their twined hair, steeped and sparkling; farther on,

Tall rushes and thick flag-knots have combined

To narrow it; so, at length, a silver thread

It winds, all noiselessly, thro’ the deep wood,

Till thro’ a cleft way, thro’ the moss and stone,

It joins its parent-river with a shout.

 

The poem is dated Richmond, Oct. 22, 1832: it bears no name, and carries the stamp of no poet with whose works we are intimate. We hope the author’s next strains will be more cheerful, and as original as these: the day is past, we fear, for either fee or fame in the service of the muse; but to one who sings so naturally, poetry must be as easy as music is to a bird, and no doubt it has a solace all its own.

[Allan Cunningham]

Reviewed:

Pauline (RB), London: Saunders & Otley, 1833.

___________________

National Endowment for the Humanities - Logo

Editorial work on The Brownings’ Correspondence is supported by the National Endowment for the Humanities.

This website was last updated on 7-25-2026.

Copyright © 2026 Wedgestone Press. All rights reserved.

Back To Top